Is there a difference?
Yes.
A "boat shoe" is a style of shoe, while a "boating shoe" is a shoe worn boating. Am I being smug? Annoyingly, yes.
The Sperry Boat Shoe is obviously the most popular, the sole for which is rumored to have been modeled after a dog's paw. The lacing starts at the heel, continues forward, alternates through eyelets, and finishes with whatever type of knot you can come up with at the top. In theory, the lacing is meant to cinch the topline to the ankle. The white sole serves the same purpose that a squash shoe requires: the soles are non-marking. Black rubber-soled running shoes leave streaks on teak, fiberglass, and the nice floors of squash courts, which are nearly impossible to remove. A slightly beveled heel allows added grip to ratlines and footropes when going and working aloft. The thick leather provides protection and structure, making the shoe surprisingly effective for tucked-toes under the gunwhales during high wind sailing in dinghies and open boats.
Up until the about 1999 or so, they were still the most popular sailing shoe in the Northeast, and during races the row of tanned legs dangling over the weather rail would be shod in Topsiders only... rain or shine.
They were favored by sailors and yacht clubs for two very simple but important reasons:
1. They were effective and superior boating shoes, and
2. They satisfied the dresscode at most yacht clubs and seaside restaurants (even when wet).
As a casual shoe, they were popular because they were comfortable, more "dressy" than athletic shoes, but mostly because people already had them.
Men and boys wore them throughout the winter with socks and nearly all manner of pant, while women and girls wore them with skirts and knee-socks, jeans, kilts, and khakis. Bleachers were always, ALWAYS filled with Topsiders during school games both on students and on visiting parents.
True signs of the boating shoe's wearer using them correctly:
-Green-oxidized eyelets from the sea's salt
-Retro-fitted with open brass grommets on the instep for better ventilation/water draining
-4th set of leather laces (or replaced fully with synthetic cords for the offshoremen)
-Regularly treated with wax polish or oil
-Disproportionately unworn sole compared to mangled toe and heel sections of the leather
Offshore sailors tend to not slip them on or off, preferring to untie and retie them each time. If they can be slipped on and off in the house, they will certainly slip off when the deck is fully awash during heavy seas.
One drawback to the boating shoe is that the sole is relatively hard and solid, giving the foot a flattened soreness after a full day's sailing or strolling.
It's doubtful that the new generation of sailors will adopt this shoe seriously. If their parents, camp counselors, baby-sitters, and sailing instructors are not wearing them, why would they?
As a young college man, my pulse would always quicken when I would catch a glimpse of a gal in Topsiders worn with a skirt, which showed that she was either a coastal Yankee skeptical of popular fashion or she was an exchange student, and I could attempt to impress her with the only two Dutch words I knew and would inevitably butcher.
"Where are you from?" I asked.
"Montevideo," she said somewhat coldly.
"Oh... I thought I heard you speaking Dutch," I said, thrown off.
"I was," she said as she stared plainly.
"Isn't Montevideo in Paraguay?" I said, giving a last lurch at a dignified exchange.
"No, it's in Uruguay. I went to school in the Netherlands."
"Uhhh... mmm... well..." I sputtered as my cocktail small-talk arsenal evaporated.
"Have a good evening" she said, putting me out of my misery.
These days, one can get a boating or boat shoe in any sort of color, material, and style. If you are using them for sailing or boating, they must have non-marking soles. Other than that, find a brand and style you like and have at it. I'm not a staunch purist when it comes to the brands. For the record, the single best pair I have ever purchased were at a shop near Searsport, Maine in 1998 and they were made by Dexter. They have outlasted three pair of Sperry's throughout everything from coastal to blue-water sailing, so don't feel heckled or pressured into just one manufacturer.
Yes.
A "boat shoe" is a style of shoe, while a "boating shoe" is a shoe worn boating. Am I being smug? Annoyingly, yes.
The Sperry Boat Shoe is obviously the most popular, the sole for which is rumored to have been modeled after a dog's paw. The lacing starts at the heel, continues forward, alternates through eyelets, and finishes with whatever type of knot you can come up with at the top. In theory, the lacing is meant to cinch the topline to the ankle. The white sole serves the same purpose that a squash shoe requires: the soles are non-marking. Black rubber-soled running shoes leave streaks on teak, fiberglass, and the nice floors of squash courts, which are nearly impossible to remove. A slightly beveled heel allows added grip to ratlines and footropes when going and working aloft. The thick leather provides protection and structure, making the shoe surprisingly effective for tucked-toes under the gunwhales during high wind sailing in dinghies and open boats.
Up until the about 1999 or so, they were still the most popular sailing shoe in the Northeast, and during races the row of tanned legs dangling over the weather rail would be shod in Topsiders only... rain or shine.
They were favored by sailors and yacht clubs for two very simple but important reasons:
1. They were effective and superior boating shoes, and
2. They satisfied the dresscode at most yacht clubs and seaside restaurants (even when wet).
As a casual shoe, they were popular because they were comfortable, more "dressy" than athletic shoes, but mostly because people already had them.
Men and boys wore them throughout the winter with socks and nearly all manner of pant, while women and girls wore them with skirts and knee-socks, jeans, kilts, and khakis. Bleachers were always, ALWAYS filled with Topsiders during school games both on students and on visiting parents.
True signs of the boating shoe's wearer using them correctly:
-Green-oxidized eyelets from the sea's salt
-Retro-fitted with open brass grommets on the instep for better ventilation/water draining
-4th set of leather laces (or replaced fully with synthetic cords for the offshoremen)
-Regularly treated with wax polish or oil
-Disproportionately unworn sole compared to mangled toe and heel sections of the leather
Offshore sailors tend to not slip them on or off, preferring to untie and retie them each time. If they can be slipped on and off in the house, they will certainly slip off when the deck is fully awash during heavy seas.
One drawback to the boating shoe is that the sole is relatively hard and solid, giving the foot a flattened soreness after a full day's sailing or strolling.
It's doubtful that the new generation of sailors will adopt this shoe seriously. If their parents, camp counselors, baby-sitters, and sailing instructors are not wearing them, why would they?
As a young college man, my pulse would always quicken when I would catch a glimpse of a gal in Topsiders worn with a skirt, which showed that she was either a coastal Yankee skeptical of popular fashion or she was an exchange student, and I could attempt to impress her with the only two Dutch words I knew and would inevitably butcher.
"Where are you from?" I asked.
"Montevideo," she said somewhat coldly.
"Oh... I thought I heard you speaking Dutch," I said, thrown off.
"I was," she said as she stared plainly.
"Isn't Montevideo in Paraguay?" I said, giving a last lurch at a dignified exchange.
"No, it's in Uruguay. I went to school in the Netherlands."
"Uhhh... mmm... well..." I sputtered as my cocktail small-talk arsenal evaporated.
"Have a good evening" she said, putting me out of my misery.
These days, one can get a boating or boat shoe in any sort of color, material, and style. If you are using them for sailing or boating, they must have non-marking soles. Other than that, find a brand and style you like and have at it. I'm not a staunch purist when it comes to the brands. For the record, the single best pair I have ever purchased were at a shop near Searsport, Maine in 1998 and they were made by Dexter. They have outlasted three pair of Sperry's throughout everything from coastal to blue-water sailing, so don't feel heckled or pressured into just one manufacturer.
Purchased my first pair last summer, and they are about all I wear in the afternoons and evenings at home now during the warmer months now. And they sure beat sneakers, Tevas, and flipflops in the looking-pulled-together department! Goodness knows I hardly see any other men (or women) wearing shoes like these in my neck of the woods.
ReplyDeleteBest Regards,
Ulrich von B.
In my life I have spent exactly 2 hours on a sailboat and countless hours in boat shoes.
ReplyDeleteAs one who was raised to know how to pull Dad's cowboy boots off by pulling with both hands from the heel, I was thought quite pretentious for preffering boat shoes.
Lets not even talk about Wranglers. Some must work to undo our upringing.
Hey Matador! Most of those guys were likely wearing either white sperrys or white sneakers. Some of them still are - lol!
ReplyDeleteDexter is such a Maine shoe. I used to frequent their seconds store just over (or before, depending on your direction) the Wiscasset Bridge in Edgecomb. Good point about brand preferences.
ReplyDeleteI just mentioned this on Muffly's blog actually. I have three pairs of boat shoes, two of them are "boating" shoes, to use your terminology. I sail rather small boats, J24s and the like, and I'm very rarely not in Sperry's for the duration.
ReplyDeleteI also wear them lots of other places, but they generally get deck wear, because they ought to be worn on deck!
Well said. Practically grew up in the things.
ReplyDelete*Prinz: Last summer? Better late than never!
ReplyDelete*Bro-ha: I am the opposite... I have never worn cowboy boots. I have spent as much time on a horse as you have in a sailboat.
*Patsy: Yes, indeed. We know some of the same folks.
Lady Aldrich: The soles of the Dexters are slightly thinner and harder, but they make a tough shoe. Keep them waxed (but not shined) with Kiwi and they will last forever.
*Kionon: Topsiders are best in small boats, especially those without hiking straps. J-24's are respectably sized boats.
*LBF: Even our lifeguards wore them.
I went for Sperry Stripers or Chuck Taylors to the ramp, kicked 'em off to race barefoot in Beetles and then Sunfish through my teens. 'Dress' shoes at the beach were Bean's camp mocs or Bluchers (both highly trendy among the coastal prep school crowd in the '80s). Either of those shoes would get you into church but not onto an offshore racer. So it seems we missed the point of mocs.
ReplyDeleteHad 'em all, but haven't put a Topsider on my feet in 30 years. Can't bring myself to buy them again, even though I have pretty much regressed to only wearing the same clothes I wore when I was a teenager. By my inspection of what's being sold today, the currently available logo-emblazoned Topsider isn't anywhere near as well made as it was 40 years ago, and besides I'd feel a fool wearing them. Sailed as a boy (was on the sailing team at my East coast prep school), haven't been closer to a boat than the Nantucket Ferry (where I am headed later today) in ten years. I'm sticking with the Bean Vamp Moc, even though that's a sad story, too, compared to the ones I wore way back when. Harumph! Reggie
ReplyDeleteI've had Tops on my feet some part of everyday for near 40 years. I'm near convinced though that Sperry makes Beans shoe, which is marginally less expensive and holds up a bit better.
ReplyDeleteCould you cover the correct occasion and attire to pair with the suitable brands for Tassels and Penny Loafers next? Your insight would be much appreciated.
ReplyDeleteI'm not generally a shameless self-promoter (or a promoter at all), but I think many of you may be interested in the post I wrote on caring for boat shoes:
ReplyDeletehttp://kyotomaiko.blogspot.com/2011/08/proper-care-and-feeding-of-boat-shoe.html